Private vs Government Health Insurance in Nigeria

Health insurance in Nigeria has grown beyond a luxury—it’s now a practical step toward surviving an unpredictable healthcare system. But when it comes to choosing between private and government insurance, many Nigerians are unsure of which is better or more reliable.

Should you go for a private Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) or enroll in a government-supported scheme like the National Health Insurance Authority (NHIA)? Which one gives better hospital access, faster response, or wider coverage? To help you make a smart decision, this article compares both options, showing where each one works best, where they fall short, and what kind of user they are best suited for.

What Is Private Health Insurance?

Private health insurance is managed by companies known as Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs). These are profit-driven firms licensed by the National Health Insurance Authority to sell health plans to individuals, families, and businesses. Examples of private HMOs in Nigeria include:

• Reliance HMO
• Avon HMO
• Hygeia HMO
• AXA Mansard Health
• Redcare HMO

These companies create their own health plans, hospital networks, and customer service structures. They operate across various states and are not directly funded by the government.

What Is Government Health Insurance?

Government health insurance is mostly managed by the NHIA (formerly NHIS) or through state-led schemes. These programs are designed to provide affordable health coverage to civil servants, low-income families, students, and informal workers.

Popular examples include:

• NHIA Family Health Plan
• Lagos State Health Scheme (LSHS)
• Kwara Health Insurance
• Oyo State Health Insurance Agency (OYSHIA)

Government schemes focus on making healthcare accessible to a wider group of Nigerians, especially those who can’t afford private HMO plans.

Coverage: Who Offers More Services?

Private health insurance tends to offer more flexible and extensive coverage. Most private plans include:

• Outpatient and inpatient care
• Emergency treatments
• Prescribed medications
• Minor and major surgeries
• Specialist consultations
• Eye and dental care (on higher plans)
• Maternity and childbirth care
• Diagnostics like scans and X-rays

On the other hand, government insurance schemes cover more basic needs. They usually include:

• Routine doctor visits
• Basic lab tests
• Medications for common illnesses
• Antenatal and postnatal services
• Child immunizations
• Minor surgeries

While the coverage is decent, it is limited compared to what higher-tier private plans provide. Government insurance often excludes complex surgeries, international treatments, or brand-name drugs.

ALSO READ: How to Choose the Right Health Insurance Plan

Cost: Which Is More Affordable?

Government insurance is usually cheaper. Plans under NHIA or state programs range from ₦8,000 to ₦20,000 per year. These are designed to be accessible to unemployed individuals, low-income earners, and rural families.

Private HMOs, while more flexible, come at a higher cost. Basic plans start around ₦15,000 to ₦25,000 annually for individuals and can go up to ₦100,000 or more depending on coverage and hospital network.

If you’re looking for budget coverage and don’t need high-end services, government plans may be a better fit. But if you need fast service and broader care options, private HMOs offer better value—even if they cost more.

ALSO READ: Affordable Private Health Insurance Options in Nigeria

Speed and Service Quality

This is where private insurance has the edge. Private HMOs often provide:

• Faster hospital authorization
• Shorter waiting time at clinics
• 24/7 customer care and doctor access via apps
• Quick response to complaints
• Smooth referral process to specialists

Government schemes, on the other hand, are often slowed down by bureaucracy. Some users report delays in treatment approval, longer queues, and challenges reaching support services. Hospitals that accept NHIA cards may also prioritize private patients over government-insured ones.

However, some state schemes are improving in these areas by partnering with reputable private hospitals and setting up digital support channels.

Hospital Networks

Private HMOs usually offer more options in terms of hospital choice, including access to premium clinics and specialist hospitals. Users can pick facilities close to their location, and many HMOs allow switching hospitals when needed. Government plans have a more limited list of partner hospitals. These are often public or low-cost facilities. While some private clinics are included, the number is smaller and often restricted by region.

If you live in a city like Lagos or Abuja, both options may offer decent hospital networks. But in rural areas, private HMOs tend to have fewer registered hospitals, while government programs sometimes have better reach through public health centers.

Ease of Registration and Use

Private health insurance plans are generally easier to register for. Most allow online sign-up through their websites or apps. Some even offer in-app doctor consultations and digital health cards.

Government plans often require more paperwork, physical visits to registration centers, and delays in activation. However, this is changing in some states that have adopted digital systems for enrolling new members.

For example, the Lagos State Health Scheme allows online payment and mobile registration, making it more convenient than older NHIA processes.

ALSO READ: Best Health Insurance Plans for Low-Income Families

Who Should Consider Private Insurance?

Private health insurance is ideal for:

• Working professionals who want premium care
• Families who can afford mid- to high-tier plans
• People with chronic illnesses who need regular care
• Users who prefer shorter waiting times and responsive customer service
• Individuals who travel frequently and need hospital options across states

It’s also a better option if you want dental, eye, specialist, or mental health services, which are rarely included in government plans.

Who Should Consider Government Insurance?

Government-backed health insurance is more suitable for:

• Low-income households
• Informal sector workers
• Rural families and communities
• Students in public universities
• Unemployed individuals who can’t afford private plans
• Civil servants or pensioners already linked to NHIA schemes

Though it may have limitations, it still offers better access than having no insurance at all.

Can You Use Both?

Yes, in some cases. For example, someone might be enrolled in a state insurance plan but still buy a private policy for broader coverage. This is common for families who use government insurance for basic care but need private coverage for childbirth, surgeries, or chronic illnesses. However, claims cannot be made from both plans for the same service at the same time. You’ll need to pick which plan to use for each treatment.

ALSO READ: Top 10 Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) in Nigeria